495 – Bonnie Raitt – Give It Up


I have 2 other Bonnie Raitt albums – ‘Nick of Time’ and ‘Luck of the Draw’ so I am expecting good things from this one…

So, this for me is a fairly nondescript album. It is well played and sung but  just not particularly memorable. It seems a strange choice for the top 500 when other excellent female artists are notable by their absence. Rickie Lee Jones, Nanci Griffith, Alison Krauss and Joan Armatrading to name four immediately.

I say this as someone who likes Bonnie Raitt – ‘ Something to Talk About’ on ‘Luck of the Draw’ is a particularly fine example. I have to once again echo the sentiments of t’wife, I can’t imagine myself ever returning to this one. I struggle to pick out any I would really recommend (or indeed remember tomorrow).

‘I know’ isn’t too bad- if a bit schmaltzy, same goes for ‘You got to Know How’ and ‘Under the Falling Sky’ is almost there – just falls slightly short.

The first few seconds of ‘Love has no pride’ make me instantly think of ‘Do you really want to hurt me’ for some bizarre reason (this was the one that made Blog Connoisseur think of Sheena Easton). I know there is no real resemblance but something about the initial chord progression makes it pop into my head straight away.

Anyway, scores on the doors, 8/20, although I find it pretty hard to rate as I don’t actively dislike it, just don’t particularly like it either – sorry Bonnie.





496 – Boz Scaggs – Boz Scaggs


Time for a bit of Boz..

I only really know the ‘Silk Degrees’ album having been introduced to it by a good friend of mine (cheers Anton). I am looking forward to exploring a little more Boz.

OK, have to agree with the comment by ‘Blog Connoisseur’ here, it washed over me a bit to start with. Not any single track that grabbed me like the oft-played ‘Lido Shuffle’, however (and there seems to be a bit of theme so far), this is another real grower with some fabulous soulful songs.

‘I’ll be long gone’, is a real slow-burner and I have found myself returning to this a few sneaky extra times.

‘Another day, another letter’ is another cracker and I can definitely see myself returning to this – I just wish it was a bit longer and the fade at the end a bit more subtle!

Actually I think that the ‘fader master’ was a bit heavy handed on a few of them.

‘Now that you’re gone’  for some reason makes me think of ‘Goodnight ladies’ by Lou Reed, no idea why – just does.

‘Finding Her’ is also just a really ‘good’ song, arrangement and delivery, which also reminds me of something else I cant quite put my finger on – somebody also obviously has had a word about the fades on this one and went the other way.

‘Sweet release’ is fabulous, the song and arrangement are also very reminiscent of Van Morrison – not a bad thing in my book.

I would put the album at 14/20, not really sure about a favourite, probably ‘Finding Her’, ‘I’ll be long gone’ or ‘Sweet Release’  all 14/20 ish. But there are no ‘potato peelings’ on the album, to steal a phrase from Phil B.

My least favourite is ‘Loan Me a Dime’ but that is probably because I have never coped particularly well with 12 minute tracks in general and because its style and delivery just aren’t my favourite. The track is well done, just not really my thing – even though it was the most popular on the album at the time apparently.

One major issue though…

For me, there is a time and a place for yodelling, and  I am not sure this (or any album for that matter) is it. Happy to be put right on the subject of suitably high quality yodelling tunes though, by more knowledgeable people than I. Every time I hear ‘Waiting for a Train’ I am lulled into a false sense of security thinking to myself I really like this one and then, bang! – …. ‘slam the box car door – Yodel eehee’.

Update, having listened again, maybe Boz is even managing to turn me into an appreciator of yodelling !


497 – The White Stripes – White Blood Cells


On a roll now…

For me this album was always really only about ‘Hotel Yorba’, so lets see what the rest of it is like on ‘listen again’..

Got this one on vinyl only..

white stripes on sofa

So, I quite like the White Stripes, I have 2 albums and have seen them live a few times (always as part of festivals though, never at one of their own gigs). However, I don’t initially think that this album is one that is actually designed to be listened to straight through in its entirety. There are some songs that on first re-acquaintance  I actually don’t really enjoy listening to at all (to quote Alan Partridge – ‘that’s just noise’) however I do like the sound they make for the most part when the songs are strong.

At the moment its still all about ‘Hotel Yorba’..

Because there is effectively so little going on I think that the songs are quite exposed, which is a double-edged sword. When they are good they really work, but I personally don’t think it carries some of the weaker songs.

So, I am struggling with ‘The Union Forever’ and ‘i think i smell a rat’. ‘Aluminum’ I actively want to turn off.

On the other hand I the sound they make in ‘i’m finding it harder to be a gentleman’ is great. ‘Fell in Love with a Girl’ works for me as well, as does ‘The Same Boy You’ve Always Known’ and ‘We’re Going to be Friends’ is a gem.

Even when it’s good it’s not always a comfortable listen though and I think it is one where I respect what they are doing rather than really enjoy it in its entirety.

I have grown to enjoy it more over the listening period, but for me it only works in parts.


Hotel Yorba 14/20

We’re Going to be Friends 13/20

Album 11/20


498 – The Stone Roses – The Stone Roses


Only 498 – is someone having a laugh?

About to have the requisite listens, although this is an album I already know very well. ‘I Am the Resurrection’ is one of my favourite songs and this album for me is a set in stone classic.

When I first heard this in 1989, I was living in York and its release coincided with time spent with a group of close friends and our consistent approach to partying in a variety of locations across the country. It is always hard to separate music from its association with  times in your life, so I freely admit that even before I listen again this would be in my top 20.

In the early 2000’s it became one of the constituents of regular late night  (and v loud) music/hi-fi listening sessions with another v good friend of mine, which have also become legendary (at least in my head!).

No pre-existing bias there then!

‘She Bangs the Drums’ followed by ‘Waterfall’ – were the Rolling Stone reviewers listening to something else – is there a different US-based ‘Stone Roses’  who also have a similarly titled album which could explain the error?


OK, just broke out the vinyl for the last listen.  IMHO, listening to music on vinyl is a ceremony and experience which sets it apart from any other medium…

Anyway, after hopping back off my soapbox, nothing more to say except after 3 more listens it is as great as ever,not perfect but great. The quality of the songs (still not a fan of ‘Don’t stop’ though), the confidence that it all exudes.

A band at the top of their game it still gives me a massive feeling of euphoria to listen to it.

Side 1

I Wanna Be Adored 14/20

She Bangs the Drums 17/20

Side 2

Waterfall 16/20

Don’t Stop 9/20

Bye Bye Badman 12/20

Side 3

Elizabeth my Dear 10/20

(Song for my) Sugar Spun Sister 14/20

Made of Stone 15/20

Shoot You Down 14/20

Side 4

This is the One 15/20

I am the Resurrection 19/20




And just to finish – Sunday afternoon rockin’ out to ‘I am the Resurrection’ approaching 50 style.